In this article
  1. How common is it
  2. Why companies do it
  3. The nuance: not every unfilled job is fake
  4. The other silence: ghosting after the interview
  5. How to spot one
  6. What to do

You apply. You hear nothing. You apply again. Nothing. After a few weeks you start to wonder whether the job was even real. Sometimes it was not.

The short version

  • Greenhouse classifies 18–22% of the jobs posted on its platform each quarter as ghost jobs.
  • Only 4% of the companies on one major platform contact all rejected applicants. The silence is structural.
  • Not every unfilled job is fake. But enough are that it changes where you should spend your effort.

How common is it

Greenhouse runs hiring for thousands of companies, so it can measure what employers actually do rather than what they say. In any given quarter, it classifies 18% to 22% of the jobs posted on its platform as ghost jobs — listings with no real intent to hire. Roughly one in five.

In their 2024 survey of 2,500 workers in the US, UK and Germany, three in five candidates said they suspected they had encountered one. That is a suspicion, not a measurement, but it lines up with the platform data.

Clarify Capital surveyed 1,000 hiring managers and found that about half keep listings open because they are “always open to new people”. Sixty-eight percent had postings active for more than thirty days, and one in ten had postings open for six months or longer. Twenty-seven percent had simply forgotten to delete the ad.

18–22%

of jobs posted on Greenhouse in a given quarter were classified as ghost jobs (2024).

40%

of hiring managers said their company had posted a fake listing in the past year (ResumeBuilder, 2024).

Why companies do it

The reasons are less sinister than the name suggests, which does not make the experience any better. Companies keep posts open to look like they are growing. To keep current employees motivated, in a quiet “we could replace you” way. To build a pool in case someone quits. To placate an overworked team. To please a recruiter who is measured on pipeline, not hires.

Most of it is mundane administration that nobody owns. The result is the same: you spend an hour on an application for a role that was never going to be filled by anyone.

The nuance: not every unfilled job is fake

Ashby analysed 22,000 jobs posted between 2021 and 2024. Eighty-two percent were filled. Eighteen percent were not — but of those, 5.5% were paused, 1% had an offer that was declined, and only 3.5% had no reason recorded. And 97.5% of jobs at companies with fifty or more employees moved at least some candidates to an interview stage.

So “no hire” and “fake job” are not the same thing. Budgets freeze. Priorities change. An internal candidate appears. A real role can close without anyone being hired, and that is bad luck rather than a con.

The other silence: ghosting after the interview

Ghost jobs are only half the story. Greenhouse also found that 61% of candidates had been ghosted after an interview — up nine percentage points year over year. Historically underrepresented candidates reported it even more often.

And in the second quarter of 2024, only 4% of roughly 6,500 companies on Greenhouse contacted every rejected applicant. The silence after a “you’ll hear from us” is not a judgment on you. It is a process with no owner, run by people who are already behind.

How to spot one

  • Posted more than thirty days ago, especially if it has been reposted with a fresh date.
  • No salary range, no team, no hiring manager, no start date.
  • “Always hiring” or “evergreen” language.
  • The same role appears in five cities with identical text.
  • The company recently announced a hiring freeze or layoffs. Check the news before you invest an hour.
  • A named recruiter never responds, even to a short, specific message.

What to do

Apply in the first week. Fresh postings have smaller piles, and a recruiter is more likely to be actively working the role.

Prioritise companies with a named recruiter or hiring manager, and ask for a referral whenever you have any connection. A human forwarding your file beats any portal, and it tells you whether the role is real.

Track your applications. If a company has not responded in three weeks and the posting is still up, treat it as closed and move on. Spend your tailoring time on roles that show signs of life.

A ghost job is not a verdict on your resume. It is a listing that was never a door. The useful skill is telling the difference faster, and putting your effort where there is an actual room.

Sources

  1. Greenhouse, 2024 State of Job Hunting report
  2. Axios, how Greenhouse is taking on job ghosting (2024)
  3. Clarify Capital ghost jobs survey, via Audacy
  4. ResumeBuilder, 3 in 10 companies currently have fake job postings listed (2024)
  5. Ashby, how common are ghost jobs? (2025)

Musab Hassan Ahmed

Founder, SubMac

Musab Hassan Ahmed is the founder of SubMac, a resume tailor that never invents experience. He writes about hiring, applicant tracking systems, and the gap between how companies say they hire and how they actually do.

Check your own resume against a real job ad.

Match score and two previews before you pay. $1 only if you like the tailored version.

Check my match score